Press "Enter" to skip to content

Senate Opens Impeachment Trial, Hears Opening Arguments in Ravnsborg Case

I’m watching the Senate impeachment trial of killer and suspended Attorney General on South Dakota Public Broadcasting. Senate President Larry Rhoden has just called a 15-minute recess following the opening statements. Here’s what we’ve heard so far:

  • Clay County State’s Attorney Alexis Tracy led off with a strong summary of the evidence supporting the two articles of impeachment: that Ravnsborg caused the death of Joseph Boever and then abused his office and lied to law enforcement about what happened. Co-prosecutor and Pennington County State’s Attorney Mark Vargo did not speak.
  • The defense opened with testimony from Washington DC lawyer and Tulane instructor Ross Garber, who spoke not about the details of Ravnsborg’s case but about the rare occurrences of impeachment in other states and his own successful effort to defend South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford from impeachment. Opening with Garber seemed a complete political misstep: bring a Beltway lawyer to tell South Dakota Senators how their impeachment process should work? Whose brilliant idea was that?
  • But start weak, finish strong: Ravnsborg’s defense attorney Michael Butler than took the podium (and keep in mind what a rare privilege it is to speak from that dais; Senators speak from the floor, not the lower podium below the Senate President’s august perch) to emphasize that:
    1. Jason Ravnsborg has never been found criminally culpable of causing Joe Boever’s death;
    2. Jason Ravnsborg cooperated fully with the investigation of his fatal car crash at every stage;
    3. Jason Ravnsborg offered to take a polygraph test but the North Dakota Bureau of Criminal Investigation chose curiously not to administer one;
    4. Jason Ravnsborg may have been mistaken, but he did not lie to police;
    5. The House impeachment investigation committee concluded that undue influence had been exerted to secure impeachment by robocalls, billboards, and Secretary of Public Safety Craig Price. Butler did not name the Governor in this campaign of undue influence. To the Senate, Butler said, “I trust that the line has been drawn and that will not occur here”;
    6. The public may have all sorts of opinions, but they “may not understand what impeachment entails… they are not fully informed…” and the Senate should make its decision about Ravsnborg’s fate based on the evidence and the legal standards presented in this trial.

3 Comments

  1. Bob Newland 2022-06-21

    Early on, Butler referred to “Jason” Boever.

    100% of the time. Butler pronounced his client’s name as if it were spelled “Ravvensberg.” Everyone else, including his client, pronounces it as if it were spelled “Rounsborg” (or …berg)Berg. Weird.

  2. Bob Newland 2022-06-21

    I, too, am unclear as to why the polygrapher declined to administer a polygraph exam on Ravnsborg. The polygrapher’s explanation of that seemed self-contradictory.

  3. Arlo Blundt 2022-06-21

    Well…I’m glad the defense attorneys are putting a little heat on the nimrods in the Senate who make law without understanding law…we used to decry the fact that the legislature especially the Senate had so many lawyers in its ranks. The current group includes way too many numbskulls and young careerists with no training in the law. I hope that it turns out that Ravensborg is turned loose to pursue other endeavors but the people of this state deserve a fair trial with an intelligent jury.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.