Skip to content

SDGOP Autism Advocate Silent on Trump’s Misstatements

GOP spin blogger Pat Powers cares so much about autism that he’s willing to advocate big government intrusion in the marketplace to make sure his cause is supported.

Donald Trump, tweet, 2017.04.02.
Donald Trump, tweet, 2017.04.02.

But autism-advocate Powers apparently can’t bring himself to violate his Dear Leader principles. While Donald Trump lit the White House blue yesterday evening for Autism Awareness Day, he has lit up autism advocates with his apparent misunderstanding of autism. Yet Powers has not raised his voice alongside his fellow autism advocates to point out his President’s errors.

Trump issued a White House proclamation Friday recognizing World Autism Awareness Day. That proclamation speaks of genetic research (the Trump budget would cut a fifth of the budget of the National Institutes of Health, which conducts genetic research on autism) to “ultimately, find a cure” for autism.

Cure? Believe it or not, that’s not the right word to use with autism advocates:

President Trump’s proclamation pledges that his administration will encourage “innovation that will lead to new treatments and cures for autism.” Such a goal is widely outside the consensus of the self-advocate community, which has long since concluded that the concept of a “cure” for autism is profoundly unethical and leads to dangerous and even deadly consequences for autistic people. It is also out of line with the consensus of the scientific community, which has recognized the idea of cure as scientifically implausible. Research towards “cure” does not help autistic people or our families, and after decades of protest from autistic people, the public has begun to realize that a world without autistic people is not an ethical or desirable goal. The Trump administration’s attempt to revive the idea of cure is a dangerous fringe position [Autistic Self Advocacy Network, statement, 2017.04.01].

Such ignorant “cure” talk arises naturally from Trump’s complete, hermetic self-absorption:

It’s not surprising that Trump is still looking for a “solution” to autism. I doubt he’s spent much time talking to autistic adults, or learning more about their support needs. That would require a willingness to accept a different worldview, and I’ve yet to see that from Trump. But by focusing on autism as something to prevent, treat, or cure, Trump is doing kids like mine a disservice, and reinforcing the idea that who they are isn’t good enough [Jody Allard, “The New President’s Ignorance about Autism Is Dangerous for Kids Like Mine,” CafeMom, 2017.02.15].

Governor Dennis Daugaard manages to avoid the word “cure” in his autism awareness proclamations. Last year Powers found autism awareness proclamations from Governor Daugaard and Sioux Falls Mayor Mike Huether positive and newsworthy. Yet he fails to notice a proclamation from his President that gets his issue wrong.

While celebrating socialist policies supporting his autism advocacy, Powers has noted that claiming that autism is increasing due to vaccines is “crazytalk“. Yet Powers has ignored his President’s peddling of exactly that crazytalk. In February, at a White House meeting with fellow no-clue-itarian Betsy DeVos, Trump referred to the “horrible… tremendous amount of increase” in autism. That statement is bunk:

Trump is broadcasting a very inaccurate and misleading claim about autism — one that you often hear from the Kennedys and Wakefields of the world, but which experts flatly disagree with. Purveyors of this claim often point out that autism rates have increased significantly since the early 1990s, but as Steve Silberman, an autism expert and the author of NeuroTribes: The Legacy of Autism and the Future of Neurodiversity, told Science of Us, that has to do with diagnostic criteria and awareness, not the prevalence of the condition itself.

“There’s no consensus as to whether or not there’s been any significant increase in the actual prevalence of autism, period,” said Silberman [Jesse Singal, “Donald Trump Just Broadcast a Dangerous Misconception about Autism Rates,” New York Magazine, 2017.02.14].

The autism-increase myth is a fundamental assumption of the anti-vaccine movement, another unhealthy bit of anti-science that Trump has promoted.

Trump is now using the highest office in the country to broadcast language and falsehoods that run counter to the conscientious autism advocacy of people like Powers… yet Powers remains silent on the damage the pulpit bully is doing.

Come on, Pat: I wasn’t afraid to say President Obama was wrong on issues that are near and dear to my heart, like education, or when he didn’t push hard enough for liberal priorities, like single-payer health insurance or a public option. You can do it, too, Pat: you can say, “Trump is wrong: autism doesn’t need a cure; it needs more science, more understanding… and more socialism!”

4 Comments

  1. Rorschach

    He’s too busy pasting press releases to catch up on the latest from President Trump. And ruminating on such information to twist it into something positive takes time. He still hasn’t gotten to the failure of Trumpcare/Ryancare/Noemcare. First things first.

  2. Our Preznit also designated April as Sexual Assault Awareness and Prevention Month.
    His “cure” for autism can be seen (fictionally, of course) in “The Man In the High Castle.”

  3. Ruminating? An apt verb, Ror, in that at best, Powers only chews the cud of what his sponsors have fed him before producing his cow-flops.

    (Bucko, at peril of getting off track, I’ll suggest that Donald Trump’s awareness of sexual assault pre-White House seems to have been less about prevention and more about opportunity.)

  4. Douglas Wiken

    Trump and co-conspirators are anti-science, anti-logic, anti-real data, anti-reality. They are hazardous to physical and social health. Thune, Noem, and Rounds are equally ignorant of science and the scientific method. Thune’s Bible college education is not a match for global warming, the herd effect of innoculations, etc. Noem is ignorant of everything except extracting money from family crop insurance business. Rounds is all about milking the public misery with his insurance business and the more misery, the more income. This collection of Republican anti-science, pro-mythology fools are a bad joke on South Dakotans, but blindly voting for any yellow, crippled, blind, deaf dog with an R after there name gets them what they deserve. Unfortunately, the rest of us have to put up with their crappy representation and nonsense blather.

Comments are closed.