Press "Enter" to skip to content

Manufacturing Jobs Declining in South Dakota Even Before Coronavirus

FDIC analyst Richard Cofer did a lot more in his presentation to the South Dakota Banking Commission last week than just prove that Governor Kristi Noem lied about South Dakota’s coronavirus jobs recovery. His slideshow includes a troubling graph showing that manufacturing jobs in South Dakota were slumping well before the pandemic hit:

Richard Cofer, Jr., Regional Manager, FDIC Division of Insurance & Research, presentation to South Dakota Banking Commission, 2020.08.27, slide 21.
Richard Cofer, Jr., Regional Manager, FDIC Division of Insurance & Research, presentation to South Dakota Banking Commission, 2020.08.27, slide 21.

We had a fairly good trend of growth in jobs manufacturing nondurable gods prior to the pandemic, but growth in total manufacturing employment started to weaken right around when Noem’s first budget kicked in last summer, went negative by fall 2019, and has continued trending down right through the pandemic. While we’ve recovered some jobs in other sectors, South Dakota had fewer people working in manufacturing in July than it did in April:

Cofer, 2020.08.27, slide 17.
Cofer, 2020.08.27, slide 17. (annotated by CAH–DFP)

Governor Noem continues to insist to her national audience that South Dakota is a great place to grow your business. But for the past year, prior to the pandemic, manufacturers appear to have been choosing to shrink their business in South Dakota.

3 Comments

  1. leslie 2020-08-31 07:10

    Early on Noem discouraged public attendance at SE racetrack(s). Does her lying about jobs and masks now have some relation to early blowback?

  2. Debbo 2020-08-31 15:17

    Maybe people can get jobs in Sanford’s alleged child porn business?

    is.gd/HQ8vKv No paywall.

  3. Cory Allen Heidelberger Post author | 2020-08-31 19:48

    Leslie, Nome is like Annette Bosworth, just not crazy. She is testing the wind, feeling what positions get her the most buzz, the most social media likes, and, of course, the most hits on her online donation page. How that’s affecting her effort to recruit businesses won’t be known for a while.

    But apparently a trend of manufacturers cutting jobs or taking them elsewhere started well before the coronavirus pandemic hit. Why isn’t Noem’s Liberty-Rodeo act drawing more manufacturing jobs to South Dakota?

Comments are closed.