Jason Gant spent his one bumbling term as Secretary of State trying to discourage Indian voters and getting whooped in federal court for that nefarious effort. Not one for learning his lesson, Gant is now using his position as auditor in Charles Mix County to block Native votes and again getting told by a federal judge to knock it off.
According to a complaint filed in federal court the day before this year’s general election, Yankton Sioux Tribe member Lonnie Provost of Wagner went to his regular voting place at the Wagner Armory during the 2024 general election to cast his vote. He wore a t-shirt bearing the message “Natives VOTE”. On Auditor Gant’s order, poll workers ordered Provost and other folks wearing similar attire to remove or hide that message before they could vote. Some voters complied, but Provost refused to undress or redress, and the poll workers refused to hand him a ballot.
22. During the November 2024 general election, the Native American Rights Fund (“NARF”) received reports that poll workers at the Wagner Armory were prohibiting voters from wearing Native Vote shirts.
23. Reports received by NARF indicated that approximately five to twenty voters were affected. Poll workers told voters to cover their shirts or go to the restroom to remove them or turn them inside out before voting.
24. According to the reports, Gant instructed poll workers to treat the shirts as prohibited campaign materials and not to provide ballots to voters who continued wearing them.
25. The other affected voters removed or concealed their shirts and cast their ballots. Provost refused to remove his shirt and did not vote.
26. Provost wore a shirt bearing the message “Natives VOTE,” with a blue check mark and yellow and white geometric designs. Poll workers told him that he could not vote unless he removed the shirt and returned. He refused to remove it and did not cast a ballot in the November 2024 general election.
27. Plaintiff wore the shirt while seeking to vote peacefully. He did not solicit votes, distribute campaign materials, approach other voters to influence their votes, or otherwise disrupt voting. Election workers nevertheless required him to remove or conceal the shirt before they would permit him to vote. Their stated objection concerned the shirt’s message, not any disruptive conduct by Plaintiff [complaint, Lonnie Provost v. Jason Gant and Charles Mix County, U.S. District Court of South Dakota, 2026.11.02, p. 5].
Gant does not deny Provost’s allegation, instead, he justifies denying Provost his right to vote by citing South Dakota’s law prohibiting electioneering at polling places:
5. Defendant Charles Mix County Auditor Jason Gant maintains Native Vote shirts violate South Dakota electioneering statute SDCL § 12-18-3 which prohibits persons from “display[ing] campaign posters, signs, or other campaign materials or by any like means solicit any votes for or against any person or political party or position on a question” within 100 feet of a polling place.
…18. In administering the County’s election, Gant established and directed the County’s policy requiring voters to remove or conceal nonpartisan Native Vote shirts before receiving a ballot. On information and belief, Gant exercised final county policymaking authority concerning the challenged apparel determination. Election workers implemented that determination at his direction, and he reaffirmed the policy with Plaintiff’s counsel [link added; complaint, 2026.11.02, pp. 2, 4].
As Provost points out, his shirt did not solicit votes for or against any person, political party, or question on the ballot. His shirt stated in the present tense the same thing that the “I Voted” stickers the poll workers handed to voters that day said in the past tense. Neither “Natives Vote” nor “I Voted” includes any prepositional phrase saying how Provost or Natives or I or other sticker wearers are voting or did vote. Those messages express pride in voting and thus implicitly encourage others present at the polls to do so, but they don’t tell people to vote a certain way. Neither message “interferes with the voter’s free access to the polls or disrupts the administration of the polling place,” a subsequent trigger in SDCL 12-18-3 for booting someone from a polling place.
Provost maintains that his message responds to a history of Native vote suppression in Charles Mix County:
44. Native Americans have endured a long history of exclusion from the franchise and continue to face discriminatory practices and substantial barriers to registering, casting a ballot, and having their votes counted. Those barriers include distant polling places, unequal access to registration and early voting, restrictive identification and address requirements, inadequate language assistance, and voter intimidation. Against that history and those continuing obstacles, nonpartisan messages encouraging Native people to vote promote equal participation in a political process from which Native communities have too often been excluded.
45. Native Americans comprise approximately 36.5% of Charles Mix County’s population and 31.1% of its voting-age population. Despite that substantial presence, Native voters have repeatedly faced barriers to equal electoral participation in the County.
46. In Blackmoon v. Charles Mix County, Native voters successfully challenged Charles Mix County’s commission districts as violating the Fourteenth Amendment’s one-person, one-vote requirement. No. Civ. 05–4017, 2005 WL 2738954 (D.S.D. Oct. 24, 2005). After the court approved remedial districts, the court permitted the voters’ separate racial-discrimination claims to proceed, rejecting the County’s argument that redistricting rendered those claims moot. Blackmoon v. Charles Mix Cnty., 505 F. Supp. 2d 585, 592–93 (D.S.D. 2007).
47. In February 2008, the United States Department of Justice objected to the County’s proposed expansion of its Commission from three to five members and accompanying redistricting plan, concluding that the County had not demonstrated the absence of discriminatory purpose. DOJ explained that the changes would reduce Native voters’ opportunity to elect their candidate of choice from one of three districts to one of five. DOJ also cited commissioners’ knowing maintenance of districts that denied Native voters that opportunity, reports of racially discriminatory statements by commissioners, and the timing of the expansion effort following the primary victory of the County’s first Native American commissioner. DOJ further reported that the County Sheriff and deputies actively circulated the petition supporting the expansion, reportedly collecting signatures while in uniform. Letter from Grace Chung Becker, Acting Assistant Att’y Gen., U.S. Dep’t of Justice, to Sara Frankenstein (Feb. 11, 2008) [complaint, 2026.11.02, pp. 8–9].
Concerned that Gant would try again this year to suppress Native voices and votes, Provost sued Gant and the county, asking the federal court to declare that Gant’s ban on Native Vote apparel violates the right to free speech guaranteed by the First Amendment and by South Dakota’s Bill of Rights (Article 6, Section 5) and the right to vote (SD Const. Art. 6 Sec. 19 and Art. 7 Sec. 1). Provost asks the court to declare his “Natives VOTE” shirt does not violate SDCL 12-18-3 and enjoin Gant and his county from banning such legal encouragement of Provost’s Yankton Sioux brothers and sisters to participate in elections.
Recognizing the urgency of the matter, federal Judge Karen E. Schreier responded the next morning, Election Day, with a temporary restraining order telling Gant to get off Provost’s back and hand him a ballot:
“Plaintiff has demonstrated a likelihood of success on his First Amendment claim,” wrote Schreier, a Bill Clinton appointee, in her order. “His shirt conveys a nonpartisan Native voter participation message without advocating for or against a candidate, political party, or ballot measure. On the present record, defendants’ treatment of that message as prohibited campaign material lacks an objectively reasonable basis consistent with the First Amendment.”
Schreier required Gant to instruct election workers at every Charles Mix County polling place that any voter wearing the “Natives Vote” shirt or similar apparel be allowed to vote.
Following Schreier’s order, Provost successfully cast his ballot wearing the “Natives Vote” shirt [Andrew J. Nelson, “South Dakota Voter Wins Order Allowing ‘Natives Vote’ T-Shirt at Polling Site,” Courthouse News Service, 2026.11.03].
Provost got to vote, but only because the federal court again stepped in on Native voters’ behalf and told Charles Mix County to get right with the constitutions of the United States and South Dakota. Now we’ll see if Gant and the County have to write a check to cover the lawyer fees incurred to secure his speech and voting rights.