Skip to content

Comparing Legislative Elections, 2022 vs. 2026, Shows Weakness of SD Dems Blue Ripple

Right after the midterm election, South Dakota Democratic Party Chair Shane Merrill did what we expect party chairs to do: spin the election results as hard as you can for your team:

Oh, this is really, a historic night for the South Dakota Democratic Party, particularly for a lot of our young voters that have never, maybe seen these kind of wins. You know, I was maybe on the tail end of the, really what we’d call, good years, back in the late 2000s, and, so this is really special, but, hats off to our winners that came through, some really red territory actually and flipped seats that maybe even caught a few people by surprise, I would say, but I think it’s a great first step for us [SDDP chair Shane Merrill, interviewed by Meghan O’Brien, Searchlight Report Podcast Episode 41: “What South Dakota’s Blue ‘Ripple’ Means for the State Democratic Party,” South Dakota Searchlight, 2026.11.06].

I was hoping I could cheer for SD Dems like that after November 3, too, but I’m still hung up on two phenomena that distinguish South Dakota’s midterm results from much of the rest of the country: our remarkably lower voter turnout and the apparent absence of any meaningful shift in Democratic margins. For two weeks I’ve been poring over the vote counts trying to figure out what happened and to see if I’m unnecessarily and incorrectly harshing Chair Merrill’s mellow.

To test Merrill’s thesis of historic seat-flipping against my far cooler view of South Dakota’s midterm election results, let’s look at turnout and Dem results in the Senate and House contests in South Dakota’s 35 Legislative districts.

Whom Can We Compare?

For this analysis, I compare 2026 to 2022, midterm to midterm. We can’t compare district-level contests from 2026 to 2020 or to any previous election, since we redrew districts in 2021. The 2022 midterm offers a cleaner comparison than the 2024 Presidential election, since 2022 and 2026 both invited voters to vote for full slates of statewide candidates (minus attorney general in both elections, since Dems have left A.G. unchallenged since 2018) and neither year had Trump on the ballot.

But even within the midterm-to-midterm framework, only three districts offer clean and full comparisons: Districts 10 and 15 (northern Sioux Falls) and District 18 (Yankton County + northwest Clay) had one-seat Senate races with one Democrat against one Republican and two-seat House races with two Democrats facing two Republicans in both midterms.

Three more districts had full slates for both chambers in both midterms: District 11 (western Sioux Falls), District 32 (central Rapid City), and District 27 (Pine Ridge, Martin, Wall, Kadoka) contested every seat. But in 11 and 32, 2022 saw even match-ups of Democrats vs. Republicans, while those districts’ 2026 House races had just one Democrat and one outsider (Libertarian in 11, independent in 32) battling two Republicans. The comparison in District 27 is even sloppier: like 11, 27 had even Dem/GOP battles, while this year, the Senate race had turncoat Dem Peri Pourier running indy against the Democratic and Republican candidates, and the House ballot had one official Republican and four nominal independents. I’ll consider the Senate races in 11 and 32 but not their House races. I also won’t mix in the mismatched midterms from District 27.

District 26A offers another pair of equivalent midterms, one Democrat vs. one Republican for the lone House seat from the Indian-tilted half of District 26. We can also compare the District 26 Senate races, which fielded one D and one R in both midterms, but 26B had no Democratic House candidate in 2022.

Seven more districts—2 (Brandon), 7 (Brookings), 9 (northwestern Sioux Falls and Hartford), 16 (Parker, Viborg, Canton, Alcester), 22 (Huron, Redfield), 30 (Hill City, Custer, Hot Springs, Edgemont), and 33 (hilly C-shaped blob around Rapid City) had three people fighting for two House seats in each midterm, one Democrat versus two Republicans. Those Districts had no comparable Senate contests. District 33 had Senate contests both years, but 2022 brought a Libertarian challenger while 2026 brought a Democratic challenger. District 5 had three-way House races both years, but the 2022 contest pitted one Democrat against two Republicans, while this year’s three-man field had right-wing radical Neal Tapio running indy against two mainstream Republicans. Those two races thus created different voting dynamics that confound comparison.

The last three clean contest comparisons are in Districts 19 (Salem, Parkston, Freeman, Springfield) and 21 (Winner, Wagner, Platte, Plankinton), where the Senate races had mano-a-mano Dem/GOP ballots in both midterms but no comparable House races, and in single-seat House District 28A, which one-on-one Dem/GOP contests in 2022 and 2026.

If we can tolerate messier comparisons, we can bring six more districts—one fully, five partially—into our field of view:

  • District 12 (southwest-ish Sioux Falls) had two main-party Senate candidates in 2022 and 2026. 12 had two Republicans run for House both years, facing two Democrats in 2022 but only one in 2026.
  • Districts 1 (Groton, Webster, Sisseton, Britton), 14 (southeast Sioux Falls), 34 (west Rapid City), and 35 (east Rapid) don’t offer good Senate comparisons, but they did have 2D/2R House contests in 2022 and 1D/2R House contests in 2026.
  • District 17 (Vermillion, North Sioux City) went from a 1D/2R House race in 2022 to a 2D/2R House race in 2026.

So that’s 22 districts with 9 Senate races and 18 House races where we can make some reasonable comparisons between turnout and Dem fortunes in the 2022 and 2026 midterms.

How Do These Midterm Legislative Races Compare?

In the 9 comparable contested Senate races, the Republican candidates won 9,196 fewer votes than in 2022, a 20.3% drop in GOP support. The Democrats in those races won 1,597 fewer votes than their 2022 comrades, a 5.3% drop in support. Across these 9 districts where voters had a choice between a Republican and a Democrat for their next Senator, participation in making that choice dropped 14%.

In those nine contested Senate races, the only Democrats who won more votes than their 2022 district counterparts were in Districts 18 and 21. D-18’s Kay Swihart added 203 Dem votes but still lost to the most boring Senator on the prairie, Lauren Nelson, by 1,190 votes. D-21’s stalwart Dan Andersson got 204 more of his neighbors to vote blue but still lost to perhaps the craziest Senator left, Mykala Voita, by 4,217 votes.

In District 10, hard-charging Democratic Senator Liz Larson got just one vote less than she did when she first won her seat in 2022. Her opponent, Michael Dupic, let 752 votes drop out of the R column.

In the six remaining comparable Senate contests, Democrats lost votes from 2022.

Republican shed votes in eight of nine Senate contests against Democrats. The exception is District 26, which Republicans took from Democrats in 2024 and held this year. District 26 voters gave chamber-switching Rep. Rebecca Reimer 692 more votes than they gave incestophile GOPer Joel Koskan in 2022, while Bordeaux got 777 fewer votes than he got fending off Koskan in 2022.

Across all nine D-vs.-R Senate races, Democrats lost an average of 177 votes per district compared to 2022, while Republicans lost an average of 1,022 votes.

In the 12 House races that had equal numbers of Democrats and Republicans running in 2022 and 2026, Republicans won 11,404 fewer votes this year than they did in 2022. The Democrats in those races won 509 more votes than their 2022 candidates.

Districts 1, 12, 14, 34, and 35 are the five districts where Democrats had two House candidates in 2022 but put all their House bets on one Democratic challenger this year. Republicans won all ten of those House seats in 2022; Democrats won two of them this year, both in Sioux Falls, Districts 12 and 14. Those two winners both earned more votes than their highest-placing Dem counterparts in 2022. Stephanie Arne added 644 votes to the D column, a 17.8% gain over Erin Royer’s 2022 tally, to take first place and claim one House seat in District 12. Erinn Williams added 688 more votes to the District 14 Dem column, 15.1% more than Mike Huber’s 2022 haul, to place second in District 14. But the other three lone-ranger Dems in this category, in Districts 1, 34, and 35, all lost votes from their district’s 2022 third/last-place Dems. The average voter gain for House Dems across these five districts was +51. The average vote loss for their Republican competitors was –947.

District 17 House is the unique instance in which Dems ran one candidate against two Republicans in 2022 but filled the slate with two challengers this year. Republicans won both seats in both midterms. Both the Republicans and the Democrats brought in fewer votes than their 2022 counterparts—the top R shed 350 votes; the second R, 258; and the third-place Dem, 146.

Conclusion: No Historic Dem Gains

The 27 Legislative races that provide the least messy comparisons to 2022 show nothing that looks like a “historic” gain for the South Dakota Democratic Party. If history notes anything about the 2026 midterm, it will be the failure of South Dakota Democrats to catch the wave of enthusiasm and outrage that fueled truly historic upsets across the country, like Mississippi electing its first black Senator since Reconstruction. No Democratic wins came in “some really red territory”; the five House seats Dems flipped were all in urban Sioux Falls districts (10, 11, 12, 13, and 14) with below-average GOP registration and above-average Dem and indy registration. They lost their Senate seat in District 27, which has the highest Dem percentage and lowest GOP percentage in the state.

Most importantly, most of the Democratic Legislative candidates, even those who won, didn’t get more people to vote for Democratic legislators than they did in 2022. Democrats just didn’t lose nearly as many voters as their Republican opponents did.

Dems’ net gain of four seats in the Legislature puts four more Democrats on the front bench, which is four more Dems who can rock the boat in committee and in the press, but ten blue Representatives plus two blue Senators aren’t going to get to make much more policy than the current 5+3 Dem caucus. They aren’t going to get much chance to win voters back by proving what good Democratic policy can do in South Dakota.

A historic midterm in South Dakota would have meant, as it did in other states, Democrats getting more people to show up and flip a meaningful number of seats. But South Dakota Democrats didn’t seize on national sentiment to mobilize voters and put Democrats in the driver’s seat or even put a strong Democratic hand on the wheel. Instead of surfing the big blue wave, South Dakota Democrats coasted on a lucky break, that the ongoing decline in enthusiasm for their brand was, in this strange midterm election, not as bad as the wind that went out of South Dakota Republican sails.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *