Boy, the South Dakota Democrats who are running against data centers are on to something.
The SD News Watch/Chiesman poll finds South Dakotans really don’t like data centers. 57% of likely South Dakota voters told Mason-Dixon they oppose putting data centers in South Dakota. Only 23% support giving SkyNet a home in the Rushmore State. That overwhelming opposition holds across every category counted by Mason-Dixon: sex, age, region, and party. The only categories in which data center opponents outnumber proponents by less than 2 to 1 are 35–49 year olds (1.9:1), 50–64 year olds (1.6:1), and Republicans (1.4:1). Republicans and the 50–64 crowd are the only groups where support for data centers peeks above 30%.
Let’s take a look at the party-affiliation tab…

…and imagine what would happen if data centers were the galvanizing issue for this year’s midterm voters.
The average Legislative district has just about 18,000 active registered voters. Average turnout for historically recent midterms has been around 60%. That means this year we can expect around 9,500 South Dakotans to vote in the typical Legislative district. By current registration totals, that’s about 5,700 Republicans, 2,300 Democrats, and 2,700 independents casting votes for Legislature in each district.
Multiply those voter numbers by the percentages of data center opposition or support in each party, and we can estimate that, if opinion on data centers determined votes, Legislative candidates who say “No data centers in South Dakota!” would clobber candidates inviting data centers here by roughly 6,100 to 2,600, with only 2,100 undecideds remaining to split among the candidates.
| Legislative Voters | Support Data Centers | Oppose Data Centers | Undecided |
| Democratic | 255 | 1,741 | 325 |
| Republican | 1,823 | 2,621 | 1,310 |
| Independent | 487 | 1,703 | 514 |
| Total | 2,565 | 6,065 | 2,149 |
Statewide, an anti-data center candidate would outpoll a candidate unalarmed by the rise of the machines with 212,000 votes to 90,000, with only 75,000 undecideds looking for another issue to vote on.
| Statewide Voters | Support Data Centers | Oppose Data Centers | Undecided |
| Democratic | 8,936 | 60,929 | 11,373 |
| Republican | 63,808 | 91,724 | 45,862 |
| Independent | 17,035 | 59,622 | 17,981 |
| Total | 89,779 | 212,275 | 75,217 |
23 Democratic candidates for Legislature smelled that blood in the water and signed a declaration pledging to fight data centers. Democratic candidate for Public Utilities Commission Frank Kloucek has recognized the widespread alarm over data centers and called for a one-year moratorium on their expansion, while his Republican pro-corporate opponent Don Haggar has stuck his head in the Google/Meta sand.
In just a few days, we’ll find out if those Democrats can capitalize on South Dakota’s clear anti-data-center sentiment.
They need to state it clearly like Josh Turek son of
Stone in Iowa.
These data center buildings, with cooling, power, and fiber connections will be useful for a long time. However, the machines inside will prolly be obsolete by 2035.
That would be lots of indoor horse arenas, soccer fields, and roller-skating rinks for the grand kiddos.
Elon’s taking AI and it’s necessary hardware to space, baby. Yeah!
Yes, data centers are the mega-landfills of the 2020s Just as in the 1980s and 1990, and many Republican officeholders are on the wrong side of that issue, partly because their party is taking in big bucks from out-of-state billionaires who are invested in that industry.
The Republicans are pushing Amendment L to take power away from citizens and put that power into the hands of the elite big money cabal that has corrupted that party.
Amendment L needs to be defeated.
https://samfroehlkeforsd.com/news/thats-enough-of-this-ai-nonsense
I won’t go into everything I wrote in that article here, but I do think it bears repeating that data centers in space are not a real thing which can happen from an engineering standpoint.
“…data centers in space. No. You can’t cool them, you can’t run fiber to them, you can’t maintain them, you can’t get nearly the power you need, and it’s wildly cost prohibitive to even construct a fraction of what’s on earth. Just no.”
https://searchlightnm.org/tensions-increase-over-tight-timeline-for-project-jupiters-air-quality-permit/
@TorontoSam – I find you mostly right in the near term. However, your negativity and the “can’t” wording overstates your opinions. Elon’s physics are accurate but he’s betting on a cost collapse that hasn’t happened yet. My money’s on the South African, though.
*The universe is magnetic energy. Both positive and negative are necessary. I’m positive so I naturally hang out around negativity. That’s why I’m here. That and to answer my prime directive. “Examine why SD residents, think the way they do, as a group.” So far, their German American heritage is mostly responsible.
Sam and I grew up in the same part of the state. Me in Watertown. That background is my foundation. That and more curiosity than the normal SD’er.
Good luck in the election. I listened to your radio spot. Quite balanced.
@TorontoSam – LWIY (last word is yours) No need for an argument of opinions, today. Cory doesn’t like it when I disagree with him. He’s about ready to block me, I sense.
@PL – Yes, disagreement without argument is always preferable.
Obviously, the future of AI is murky, and there are both “known unknowns” and “unknown unknowns.” To set aside my personal animosity to AI for a second, and look at it dispassionately, my best guess is that the industry will move ultimately to be more on-device. And when the technology gets to that point, Apple will be the one best positioned to provide it, as they have largely stayed out of this mania now, and aren’t saddled with as much debt.